Translation of a post on the main Chinese leftist website Utopia on the limitations of ‘rights defending‘ strategies at the sharp end of China’s class war – the case of Liu Hanhuang, a young worker who lost his right hand in an industrial accident and having failed to get the compensation due via legal channels, ended up killing two of his bosses.
Liu Hanhuang – what else could he have done bar kill them?
Hearing about the Liu Hanhuang affair was enough to make your heart ache and set you weeping. Whatever other people might say, we remain steadfast in the belief that Liu Hanhuang deserves not the slightest condemnation. All you hypocritical ‘gentlemen scholars’ with their ‘While we have every sympathy, he shouldn’t have killed people’, it’s obviously not entered your heads that aside from killing people, what could Liu have done?
Not so long back, as time and again instances of infringement on the rights of the social marginalised occurred, these elite types and experts would get up on their hind legs and gazing down from their lofty height patiently explain in sincere and grandmotherly tones to the ‘ignorant’ socially excluded: You need a rights-defending consciousness, you have to know how to protect your rights and interests in law. You refined gentlemen, you elite types fat on the contributions of the people, how come you don’t go and educate the [the government]*. Otherwise why are the people spending their money to have a [government]? The [government] can’t protect people’s legitimate rights and interests but you want people to look out for themselves – well what are they bothering to support a [government] for then? But the Chinese people are too good-hearted, they haven’t turned around and asked you this but instead they’ve listened to you to the point that over the past few years ‘rights defending’ has become a phrase on everyone’s lips. It’s got to the point where people are acting like lawyers themselves, looking up this statute, studying the law…with no help and great difficulty taking up the weapon of the law to defend their rights, and then…and then, does it get them any results?
In an age where more than ever we’re aware of the law (for which we must thank those elite types and experts) Li Hanhuang placed his hopes for defending his rights in the lawyers. He hired a lawyer and took his case to court and the court gave a judgement, that the capitalist should pay him compensation of CNY170,000. But did getting this judgement make any odds? Was Liu with a copy of this judgement in hand going to pose any threat to the capitalists? Did they not stick to their own standards for compensation; did they not continue to refuse to pay out? Having the judgement did nothing to raise Liu’s confidence, he still had to beg the capitalist for his compensation like he was asking a favour of his grandparents. But are capitalists going to melt their hearts at a bit of pleading? Are they going to feel sorry for your loss of livelihood? All they’re going to say is ‘What gives you the right to talk to me?’ This is not a road that going to take you anywhere, seems like when the elite types were advising the workers they forgot to give the capitalists any advice on applying ‘universal values’. While they were advising the workers to use the law they forgot to advise the capitalists to learn how to respect the law. In the end all the advice from the elite was only any use talking to the poor, when it came to the elite it was as much use as a fart. And when Liu Hanhuang was left with no way to pursue his claim, the elite fell silent. Isn’t that always how things have been?…As well as going down this elite-sanctioned route of legal process, Liu also tried that ‘home-made’ remedy of the helpless that has encompassed the blood and tears of so many workers – threatening to jump to his death if not paid what he was owed. At eight in the morning on the 13th of June the factory management sent security guards over to gather up Liu’s stuff and chuck it out the factory gate. Liu went to see management to argue his case but they ignored him. Pushed to the end of his tether Liu went up to the fifth floor of the dormitory preparing to jump off the building. He was pulled back by the fire brigade and so didn’t go through with it…Who’d do something like this unless they’d been driven to the very end of their tether? But even with things come to this pass, the capitalists didn’t budge an inch. (Liu Hanhuang, by contrast, gave ground time and again, ultimately asking for only CNY110,000 of the CNY170,000 the court had awarded him). Against the capitalists who’d seen it all before, this was another useless way of going about things.
At this point, Liu Hanhuang was a man all alone in a long way from home and with his right arm crippled, no job and nowhere to stay.And as a man, having put up with the obstructionism and disdain of the Zhanming factory management as he tried to claim his compensation, what was he left with other than violence as a way of protecting his rights? Surely he shouldn’t have been expected to just weakly swallow it? If he had just put up with it we’d have felt sorrow on his behalf, be he didn’t just take it, he fought back, and we applaud him. Because what I see in this is that being a man in China hasn’t disappeared altogether, there are still those with a man’s courage and self-respect, still those who’ll fight and struggle despite the heavy oppression, albeit a hopeless struggle with no aid. The truth is that today when the system is more fully established than ever, people are more tame and obedient than ever…
Having written the above, I read a news item with the title: ‘Liu Hanhuang repents his crime; kneels four times in court and asks to be given the death penalty’. I could only feela nameless sorrow that Liu Hanhuang has repented. Who really should be showing repentance here? As the case comes to its final act, we’re still left confused. Liu said, ‘I’d like the court to sentence me to death, it would be a release for me.’ In the end, our brother Liu Hanhuang could only look to death for release. And all those other people just like him, how are they going to find release?
* In the original this and the subsequent places I’ve translated as ‘the government’ were written as XX, a tactic to avoid triggering automatic Internet censoring software.
China-based Western blogger Husunzi touched on this case in his post ‘murder as weapon of the weak in postsocialist china‘, where he notes that the threat of violence has got the goods in at least one dispute:
Chen Fayuan, director of the Chengdu Municipal Supply & Marketing Cooperative [Office?], went behind the Guixi workers’ backs and sold the co-op’s store for over 220 million yuan (32 million USD).2 The workers wrote letters asking for help from various state organs, including the “National General Cooperative [Office?],” but no one was willing to help. So finally the workers decided on direct action. They put a padlock on the store so Chen or the new owners (?) couldn’t get in, and apparently they stood guard outside. The photo shows a sign they carried that reads “a blood-letting incident against corruption will soon take place”
Here the implied threat achieves the desired effect. The wider point Husunzi makes in his post as regards the lack of practical support yet being arranged online, as opposed to florid rhetoric, is the heart of the matter here.
Much-vaunted Web 2.0 networking has created space for organising previously unavailable in China but still lags a long way behind the tried and tested bonds of shared community and work-place when it comes to generating effective action. It does however provide an outlet for popular opinion that is broadly sympathetic to workers driven to violent action like Liu – I didn’t translate parts of the article above that refer to Deng Yujiao, who received clemency on the back of widespread public sympathy, mostly expressed on the Internet.
The article translated here levels some pertinent criticisms at the sometimes mealy-mouthed nature and limited utility of the ‘rights defending’ movement but it would be unfair to tar it all with this brush. I’ve met activists down in Dongguang making the best use of the law as it stands to get compensation for injured and sacked workers and they were neither elitists or under any illusions about the limits of what they could achieve. And clearly isolated acts of violence are only going to end up with more workers in prison or executed, despite the sympathy they often evoke.
With various of China’s Internet left expecting open class war from the workers in the year to come – having endured years of the same from capital and the state – it remains to be seen whether strong words and widespread sympathy expressed online will amount to much when push comes to shove.
And having just belittled Internet activism, there’s an online petition calling for a reduced sentence for Liu Hanhuang for those who care to sign.
Great post.
“I’ve met activists down in Dongguang making the best use of the law as it stands to get compensation for injured and sacked workers and they were neither elitists or under any illusions about the limits of what they could achieve.”
Don’t let Libcom read this, they’ll have you (an them) down as a bourgeoise sell-out.
good stuff jim
“neither elitists or under any illusions about the limits of what they could achieve”
sounds like a sensible/decent LCAP’ish type approach there
Excellent article, reminiscent of the early days of capitalism here when the law was used to support various enclosures and those effected were told to bring their case to law as it was there to protect them, only to find when they got to court that the judges were revealed as the enclosers – and that the same legal system and power structure then outlawed the only remaining collective response – unions and political organisations.
Create two, three many Chen Guojuns!
Those activists I met were grouped around a bloke who’d been a minor government functionary in one of the labour departments but dropped out to provide legal counselling as he thought he could do more good there. Provided all there services free and most of the staff were workers he’d helped who stayed on to become what you’d call ‘peer educators’ in trendy-speak. any road, they had one project where they’d visit A&E departments around the Pearl River Delta in a sort of ambulance-chaser way and in about two years they had a database of around 50,000 (!) incidents of industrial accidents involving the loss of fingers in the shit old machinery used in so much of manufacturing – stuff mothballed in HK as too dangerous and shipped over the border in many instances.
They’d help people pursue a comp claim and often be able to get them only a few thousand, which was hardly justice and rarely brought any hint of having a proper safety inspection at these factories (places like Dongguang apparently you have like 2 likely corrupt inspectors supposed to cover hundreds of workshops and factories – meaningless) but for the individual in question was obviously better than nothing.
China’s labour, H&S laws and so on look good on paper – and it was well seen that foreign chambers of commerce were at the forefront of lobbying against a revision to the contract law an year or so ago – but enforcement is a cruel joke, with maybe the odd white collar worker getting anything out of them and even there often where the business concerned is a softer target for wider political reasons – some unfavoured foreign enterprise etc.
Butchers hits on the bigger political point though – you’re being asked to put your faith in a legal system that not only outlaws collective response, but has been used to pursue some ridiculously vindictive responses to worker’s self defence – I mind the case in the north-east a few years back where pensioners of one state enterprise who – with this ‘rights defending’ legal knowledge in mind – organised demonstrations to claim what they were owed that were scrupulously within what the constitution and law allow, only to have four or five of the ‘ring leaders’ pursued for political crimes and sentenced to 15 years plus.
Thanks for this Jim. It can be really quite hard to get reliable left wing analysis of the sort of thing that’s happening on the ground in China. At least in English.
http://www.chinaworker.org is one useful site, much of which is in English, produced by the CWI groups in Hong Kong and mainland China. Although it seems to be down right at this very moment. Do you know of any other ones?
Was going to link to the page at China Labour Bulletin http://www.china-labour.org.hk on their legal aid work as another counter-example against the idea that rights defending is always useless, and of course they provide good analysis. Seen various what AFAIK are mainly Trotskist China-specific sites, like China Study Group http://www.chinastudygroup.org/ and China Left Review http://chinaleftreview.org/ (broadly same folks I think) but these all tend to fizzle out after a bit. Hardly unique to China that though.
Wouldn’t be looking to me for reliable analysis either!
“Wouldn’t be looking to me for reliable analysis either!”
you can’t escape the chinese desk that easy jim – 5 years you signed up for remember!
I think you mean “China Desk” unless the desk he will be sitting at is actually from China?
In a testament to my unreliability, am informed that the China Study Group is a mix of Maoists, other Marxists, lib comms and others with Trotskyists absent or few. They’ll be back up at http://chinastudygroup.net/ soon too, so that ought to be the link you bookmark.
First dispatch riddled with errors – the tradition for Western Sinology.
“unless the desk he will be sitting at is actually from China?”
what are the chances
Reading on about Liu Hanhuang, the bit in the final para of the translated article where he says in court ‘I’d like the court to sentence me to death, it would be a release for me’ makes him sound a lot more apologetic than the full quote as given here http://zggr.cn/?action-viewnews-itemid-2009:
‘It would be a release for me, but it would be an injustice for society. Because it was them who treated me unjustly first, without the original cause you wouldn’t have got the ultimate outcome. It wasn’t that I set out off my own bat to kill anyone; even know I’m still not clear why [factory management] restricted my freedom of person.’
Also notes that he knelt to apologise to the relatives of the dead men (which is traditional here), not the judge as you might get the impression from the original article. Sick irony of it is is that they’re now seeking compensation from him it seems.
For instance, how, if we exclude consensus, do we keep Intelligent Design out of biology textbooks? ,
I join. So happens. Let’s discuss this question. Here or in PM.
I always emailed this webpage post page to all my associates, since if like to read it next my contacts will too.Calvin Klein Underwear
Hello to every , because I am actually keen of reading this webpage post to be updated regularly. It contains pleasant material.Franklin And Marshall
Excellent, what a web site it is! This blog gives useful data to us, keep it up.Armani outlet
I believe this is a real enthusiastic article stake.Thanks Again. Rattling Uppercase.
Thanks for your strategies. One thing I’ve got noticed is that banks as well as financial institutions know the spending behaviors of consumers while also understand that a lot of people max away their credit cards around the breaks. They prudently take advantage of this fact and start flooding ones inbox in addition to snail-mail box using hundreds of 0 APR card offers shortly after the holiday season closes. Knowing that in case you are like 98% of all American general public, you’ll rush at the possible opportunity to consolidate credit debt and transfer balances to 0 interest rate credit cards.
It?¦s actually a nice and helpful piece of info. I?¦m happy that you simply shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.
You need to take part in a contest for one of the most useful blogs on the net. I am going to highly recommend this website!
I want to show some appreciation to you just for bailing me out of such a setting. After surfing around through the online world and seeing notions which were not productive, I thought my entire life was well over. Living without the presence of approaches to the difficulties you’ve resolved as a result of your guideline is a critical case, and the kind which might have badly damaged my career if I hadn’t noticed the website. Your own personal training and kindness in taking care of all the details was helpful. I am not sure what I would have done if I had not discovered such a point like this. I can at this point look ahead to my future. Thank you very much for your specialized and results-oriented help. I will not hesitate to endorse the sites to any person who will need direction on this subject matter.
Unquestionably imagine that that you stated. Your favourite justification appeared to be on the web the simplest factor to remember of. I say to you, I certainly get annoyed while people consider worries that they just do not recognise about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top as well as outlined out the entire thing with no need side effect , other folks can take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks
Exactly I already had looked for it and have got here rich successfully. Very good blog. Many thanks of the Koi Web
Some really wonderful information, Gladiola I observed this.
Wow! This can be one particular of the most beneficial blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Actually Great. I am also a specialist in this topic therefore I can understand your effort.
Thanks for helping out, great information. “A man will fight harder for his interests than for his rights.” by Napoleon Bonaparte.
I like what you guys are up also. Such clever work and reporting! Carry on the excellent works guys I have incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my site
.
Now, cheap A Lange Sohne Replicas are only cheap in narrative to the original fruits. There are the most prosperous imitations that imitative the certain thing to perfectness. They are handmade by experienced professionals and can be plated with certain gold and diamonds.
I conceive this web site has got very excellent written articles posts.